Lake Meadow Naturals Amish-style salted butter by Brethren Butter – rich, creamy, and small-batch churned for premium flavor. Made with farm-fresh ingredients, perfect for spreading, cooking, and baking.
Lake Meadow Naturals Amish-style unsalted butter by Brethren Butter – handcrafted in small batches for a smooth, creamy texture. Ideal for baking and cooking with pure, farm-fresh dairy goodness.

Brethren

Local

Amish Butter

Style
$8.49
Sold out? Get notified when it's back in stock!

Made from the milk of grass-fed cows, our Amish Butter is crafted with pasteurized cream to ensure safety and quality. This wholesome and natural butter is a delicious source of protein, perfect for cooking, baking, or spreading. With high-quality ingredients and a variety of options, Amish Butter is a great addition to any meal.

Please note: This butter is made with pasteurized cream to meet food safety standards.

Share

Facebook X (Twitter) Pinterest

Customer Reviews

Based on 3 reviews
33%
(1)
0%
(0)
33%
(1)
0%
(0)
33%
(1)
M
Mike Williams
Grsssfed Butter

This Grassfed Amish Butter is richer and fresher than anything you’ll find at the grocery store. The flavor is bold, smooth, and packed with a quality you can taste in every bite. It elevates any dish and beats the mass-produced stuff hands down. I highly recommend if you want real, honest grassfed butter.

Thank you so much, Mike! We're thrilled to hear you love the Grassfed Amish Butter. The rich, fresh taste is exactly why we love working with small farms that prioritize quality. Enjoy, and we appreciate your support!

Z
Zach
Pasteurized

I wouldn’t have bought this had I known it was pasteurized. I don’t feel like this belongs on an organic website.

Thank you for your feedback and for taking the time to share your thoughts. We’re sorry to hear that the Amish Butter didn’t meet your expectations. While the butter is made with pasteurized cream to ensure safety, we understand that this may not align with everyone’s preferences.

We value transparency and strive to provide detailed product descriptions. Your input helps us improve, and we’ll review how we present information to ensure customers can make informed choices.

If you have further concerns or suggestions, we’d love to hear from you directly. Thank you for helping us grow and better serve our community.

J
Jorge Diaz

Not happy about them using pasteurized milk

Thank you for your feedback. We're sorry to hear you were disappointed with the use of pasteurized milk. We strive to offer a variety of products to meet different preferences, and we appreciate your input as it helps us improve. If you have any specific requests or suggestions, we'd love to hear from you so we can better meet your expectations in the future!